Quick Dining Snapshot (Verified Accurate): Andy’s Frozen Custard serves ultra-premium, freshly made frozen custard daily with national price averages hovering between $4.50 and $9.00 per item. Standout value can be found in their seasonal promotions and multi-pack caramel apples, while third-party delivery options see a modest price increase. For complete mobile ordering convenience, check the <a href=”https://www.doordash.com/en/business/andy-s-frozen-custard-90893/menu” target=”blank” rel=”noreferrer noopener”>DoorDash Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu or find visual inspiration on the <a href=”https://www.instagram.com/popular/andy’s-frozen-custard-menu-prices?hl=en” target=”blank” rel=”noreferrer noopener”>Instagram Andy’s Menu Prices Feed to plan your custom order ahead of time.
Frozen Custard Pints & Quarts
Hand-packed throughout the day to preserve optimal density and velvety texture, these take-home containers feature pure vanilla and rich chocolate custard. They provide the perfect foundation for custom dessert nights at home or easy party hosting. Grab a couple of portions to store in your freezer for instant cravings.
| Item Name | Portion / Size | Calories | Estimated Price ($) | Dietary & Value Tags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla Pint | 16 OZ | 920 CAL | $5.49 | ⭐ Best Seller | GF |
| Chocolate Pint | 16 OZ | 980 CAL | $5.69 | 🍫 Rich Cocoa | GF |
| Twist Pint | 16 OZ | 950 CAL | $5.49 | ⭐ Fan Favorite | GF |
| Vanilla Quart | 32 OZ | 1840 CAL | $9.99 | 📦 Best Value | GF |
| Chocolate Quart | 32 OZ | 1960 CAL | $10.49 | 📦 Family Size | GF |
| Twist Quart | 32 OZ | 1900 CAL | $9.99 | 📦 Great Value | GF |
| Mint Pint | 16 OZ | 960 CAL | $6.19 | 🌿 Seasonal Feature |
| Pumpkin Pint | 16 OZ | 940 CAL | $6.19 | 🍂 Autumn Special |
| Strawberry Pint | 16 OZ | 900 CAL | $6.19 | 🍓 Real Fruit | GF |
| Peanut Butter Pint | 16 OZ | 1120 CAL | $6.49 | 🥜 High Calorie | GF |
| Blackberry Pint | 16 OZ | 890 CAL | $6.19 | 🍇 Limited Time |
| Cookies and Cream Pint | 16 OZ | 1050 CAL | $6.49 | 🍪 Loaded with Cookie |
Signature Concretes & Sundaes
Blending ultra-thick frozen custard with heavy-duty mix-ins, the signature concrete line offers over 54,000 combinations. Each cup is blended so thoroughly that it stays put even when turned upside down. Pair your choice with hot fudge, crushed cookies, or fresh fruit for maximum indulgence.
| Item Name | Portion / Size | Calories | Estimated Price ($) | Dietary & Value Tags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| James Brownie Funky Concrete | Regular | 850 CAL | $7.29 | ⭐ Top Seller | Brownie & Fudge |
| Bootdaddy Concrete | Regular | 920 CAL | $7.29 | 🍫 Chocolate Custard & Oreos |
| Ozark Turtle Concrete | Regular | 880 CAL | $7.49 | 🌰 Pecans, Caramel & Hot Fudge |
| Strawberries and Creme Concrete | Regular | 680 CAL | $6.99 | 🍓 Fresh Strawberries |
| Triple Chocolate Concrete | Regular | 940 CAL | $7.29 | 🍫 Cocoa Infused |
| Cookie Con Crete | Regular | 820 CAL | $6.99 | 🍪 Chocolate Chip Focus |
| Snowmaster Sundae | Regular | 740 CAL | $6.79 | 🍦 Marshmallow & Hot Fudge |
| PBC Concrete | Regular | 960 CAL | $7.49 | 🥜 Peanut Butter Cups |
| Raspberry Jackhammer | Regular | 810 CAL | $7.69 | 🌟 Core Drilled Center |
| Cherry Phosphate Sundae | Regular | 650 CAL | $6.29 | 🍒 Tangy & Sweet |
| S’mores Jackhammer | Regular | 890 CAL | $7.69 | 🔥 Graham Cracker & Fudge |
| Mint Cookie Concrete | Regular | 840 CAL | $7.19 | 🌿 Mint Infused |
Hand-Dipped Caramel Apples
Crisp, tart Granny Smith apples receive a thick coating of warm, buttery caramel made from scratch. Rolled generously in premium nuts, candy pieces, or chocolate sprinkles, these heavy-duty treats deliver a satisfying crunch in every single bite.
| Item Name | Portion / Size | Calories | Estimated Price ($) | Dietary & Value Tags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Classic Caramel Apple | 1 Apple | 520 CAL | $5.99 | 🍏 Pure Caramel Coating |
| Pecan Rolled Caramel Apple | 1 Apple | 780 CAL | $7.69 | 🌰 Toasted Pecans | GF |
| Reese’s Pieces Caramel Apple | 1 Apple | 840 CAL | $7.69 | 🥜 Peanut Butter Crunch |
| M&M Rolled Caramel Apple | 1 Apple | 810 CAL | $7.69 | 🍫 Colorful Candy Shell |
| Triple Chocolate Apple | 1 Apple | 860 CAL | $7.99 | 🍫 Drizzled Fudge |
| Cashew Rolled Caramel Apple | 1 Apple | 790 CAL | $7.89 | 🥜 Roasted Cashews |
| Apple Bundle 3-Pack | 3 Apples | 1650 CAL | $19.99 | 📦 Best Value Bundle |
| Apple Party Tray | 6 Sliced Apples | 3100 CAL | $38.99 | 🎉 Event Catering Size |
| Peanut Crunch Apple | 1 Apple | 760 CAL | $7.49 | 🥜 Salted Peanuts |
| Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Apple | 1 Apple | 710 CAL | $7.89 | 🧂 Gourmet Sea Salt |
| Sprinkle Birthday Apple | 1 Apple | 680 CAL | $6.99 | 🎈 Festive Rainbow |
| White Chocolate Pretzel Apple | 1 Apple | 740 CAL | $7.89 | 🥨 Salty & Sweet |
Shakes, Malts & Drinks
Crafted using real frozen custard spun slowly with fresh milk and premium flavorings, these beverages offer a luxurious thickness not found in standard fast-food shakes. Choose a traditional malt or try the specialized coffee-infused espresso blends for an afternoon pick-me-up.
| Item Name | Portion / Size | Calories | Estimated Price ($) | Dietary & Value Tags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Choco Express Shake | Regular | 780 CAL | $6.49 | ☕ Espresso & Chocolate |
| Vanilla Thick Shake | Regular | 710 CAL | $5.79 | 🥛 Classic Creamy | GF |
| Chocolate Thick Shake | Regular | 760 CAL | $5.99 | 🍫 Deep Cocoa | GF |
| Strawberry Malt | Regular | 740 CAL | $6.29 | 🌾 Malted Flavor |
| Hot Fudge Shake | Regular | 820 CAL | $6.49 | 🍫 Warm Fudge Swirl |
| Butterscotch Malt | Regular | 790 CAL | $6.29 | 🍮 Rich Butterscotch |
| Peanut Butter Shake | Regular | 880 CAL | $6.59 | 🥜 Creamy Nut Butter |
| Banana Shake | Regular | 720 CAL | $6.19 | 🍌 Real Fruit Puree |
| Oreo Cookie Shake | Regular | 840 CAL | $6.49 | 🍪 Crushed Cookie Bits |
| Root Beer Float | Regular | 480 CAL | $5.49 | 🥤 Classic Soda Float |
| Coke Float | Regular | 460 CAL | $5.49 | 🥤 Fizzy & Creamy |
| Caramel Macchiato Shake | Regular | 810 CAL | $6.69 | ☕ Espresso & Caramel |
Toppings & Mix-Ins
Customize any base custard cup or cone with an array of premium add-ins. Ranging from house-made hot fudge and toasted nuts to crushed candy bars and fresh berries, these selections let you tailor every single dessert to personal perfection.
| Item Name | Portion / Size | Calories | Estimated Price ($) | Dietary & Value Tags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hot Fudge Topping | 1.5 OZ | 180 CAL | $1.19 | 🍫 Warm & Smooth |
| Roasted Pecans | 1.0 OZ | 190 CAL | $1.29 | 🌰 Toasted Crunch | GF |
| Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups | 1.5 OZ | 210 CAL | $1.29 | 🥜 Chopped Candy |
| Fresh Strawberries | 2.0 OZ | 45 CAL | $1.39 | 🍓 Whole Fruit | GF |
| Marshmallow Creme | 1.5 OZ | 140 CAL | $0.99 | ☁️ Sweet & Fluffy |
| Butterscotch Sauce | 1.5 OZ | 170 CAL | $1.19 | 🍮 Rich & Buttery |
| Crushed Oreos | 1.5 OZ | 160 CAL | $1.19 | 🍪 Cookie Crunch |
| M&M Candies | 1.5 OZ | 200 CAL | $1.19 | 🎨 Chocolate Shells |
| Gummy Worms | 1.5 OZ | 130 CAL | $0.99 | 🐛 Chewy Candy |
| Whipped Cream | 1.0 OZ | 40 CAL | $0.79 | 🥛 Light & Airy |
| Toasted Coconut | 1.0 OZ | 160 CAL | $1.09 | 🥥 Tropical Crunch |
| Chocolate Sprinkles | 1.0 OZ | 90 CAL | $0.79 | ✨ Classic Topping |
Kiddie & Value Menu
Designed for younger appetites or lighter dessert cravings, these smaller portions offer the exact same premium frozen custard experience at a gentle price point. Perfect for quick treats after school or satisfying a sweet tooth on a budget.
| Item Name | Portion / Size | Calories | Estimated Price ($) | Dietary & Value Tags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kiddie Vanilla Cup | 4 OZ | 280 CAL | $3.29 | 👶 Kids Size | GF |
| Kiddie Chocolate Cup | 4 OZ | 310 CAL | $3.49 | 👶 Kids Cocoa | GF |
| Kiddie Twist Cup | 4 OZ | 295 CAL | $3.29 | 👶 Best Value Kids |
| Single Scoop Sugar Cone | 1 Scoop | 340 CAL | $3.79 | 🍦 Crunchy Cone |
| Mini Sundae Hot Fudge | 6 OZ | 420 CAL | $4.49 | 🍫 Small Indulgence |
| Mini Sundae Strawberry | 6 OZ | 360 CAL | $4.49 | 🍓 Fruit Topped |
| Promo Sundae of the Month | 6 OZ | 410 CAL | $3.99 | ⭐ Special Promotion |
| Plain Waffle Cone | 1 Cone | 180 CAL | $1.50 | 🧇 Fresh Baked |
| Dipped Waffle Cone | 1 Cone | 290 CAL | $2.25 | 🍫 Chocolate Coated |
| Single Dip Custard Scoop | 1 Scoop | 300 CAL | $3.69 | 🥄 Simple & Sweet |
| Junior Shake | 8 OZ | 410 CAL | $4.29 | 🥤 Small Drink |
| Puppy Cup | 2 OZ | 140 CAL | $1.49 | 🐾 Dog Friendly Treat |
Money-Saving Hacks & Secret Custom Orders
Maximize your dessert budget and discover insider menu secrets with these six expert ordering strategies:
1. Buy Pints for Group Savings: Instead of purchasing four individual regular-size concrete cups, buy a 32-ounce quart of vanilla or chocolate custard and your favorite toppings separately on the side. You will save nearly thirty percent on total cost for family dessert nights.
2. The Secret Flavor Core: When ordering any Jackhammer, ask the server to core-drill an extra-large cavity and fill it completely with hot fudge or peanut butter. Most locations do not charge an extra fee for standard substitution cores.
3. Sign Up for the Andy’s APP: Download the official Andy’s Frozen Custard mobile application to join their loyalty program. You earn points toward free treats with every purchase and receive exclusive welcome coupons for discounted concretes.
4. Kids Menu Hack for Light Eaters: If you want a smaller dessert portion during late-night cravings, order from the Kiddie menu. You receive a satisfying 4-ounce cup of premium custard for a fraction of the regular menu price.
5. Mix and Match Quart Containers: When ordering a quart, ask for a split of vanilla and chocolate custard in the same container if available. This gives you both flavor bases at the single quart bulk price.
6. Seasonal Flavor Rollover: Visit your local Andy’s during the final week of a seasonal menu rotation. Locations frequently offer promotional discounts on remaining specialty flavor pints to clear freezer space for upcoming seasonal rollouts.
Regional Pricing & Delivery Platform Markup Breakdown
Pricing for Andy’s Frozen Custard varies slightly depending on regional operating costs and sales tax structures. Standard suburban locations in the Midwest and South generally reflect baseline menu pricing. However, outlets located in high-cost metropolitan areas such as Chicago, Dallas, or coastal California frequently adjust base prices upward by 10 to 15 percent to account for elevated commercial real estate and labor expenses.
When ordering through third-party delivery applications like DoorDash, Uber Eats, or Grubhub, expect an overall menu markup of 18 to 25 percent compared to drive-thru or walk-up window rates. Furthermore, third-party apps add standard service fees, delivery distance charges, and mandatory driver tips. To secure the lowest possible price, utilize the walk-up window or mobile order-ahead feature for direct pickup.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do pints of Andy’s Frozen Custard cost?
Standard vanilla or chocolate hand-packed pints generally start around $5.49 to $5.69, depending on your location and delivery platform.
How many flavor combinations are available at Andy’s Frozen Custard?
Andy’s offers over 54,000 unique treat combinations utilizing their fresh daily custard, toppings, and mix-ins.
Does Andy’s sell items other than frozen custard?
Yes! In addition to frozen custard, concretes, and shakes, Andy’s offers hand-dipped caramel apples in flavors like classic, pecan, and Reese’s Pieces.
(Reference: Trying Ice Cream, Soft Serve, Frozen Yogurt, Custard to Find Best One – Business Insider)